Feb 18, 2019 · Is Homework Still Effective? Homework, therefore, is the result of nationalism and getting students to understand that “me time” actually falls on government time if they want to get their education. Contrary to what many websites would say, it wasn’t invented as a punishment for academically failing students. ... May 31, 2022 · But, why do we have homework? In 1905, an Italian teacher named Roberto Nevilis invented the concept of “homework.” Originally, its purpose was to be used as a punishment for students who were lazy in class or for those who were disobedient or rude to their teacher. Is homework harmful […] ... [38] [39] Homework without professional feedback from the teacher has little effect on the learning success of students. [40] Even if it is generally not wanted by homework distributors (unless homework is given as a punishment), completing homework may take up a large part of the student's free time. ... Nov 22, 2019 · Roberto Nevilis is considered the first real “inventor” of homework. According to college-homework-help.org, Nevilis is said to have created it as a punishment for students who were underachieving in his class, but those who were succeeding were exempt from completing these tasks. But the truth is, the earliest signs of education dated back ... ... Sep 3, 2022 · The concept of Homework, as we know, is not the primary goal of Nevilis. Nevilis saw it more as a means to punishment since physical punishment was not an option. Homework is essential to learning in school and is here to stay. But sometimes, kids need extra help to complete assignments, and schools and teachers should understand that every ... ... Mar 16, 2021 · Homework. Something almost everyone in school— no matter what age, grade or where they live— all dread. But, why do we have homework? In 1905, an Italian teacher named Roberto Nevilis invented the concept of “homework.” Originally, its purpose was to be used as a punishment for students who were lazy in class or... ... May 31, 2022 · Is Homework a Punishment? The Italian pedagog, Roberto Nevilis, who invented homework, initially used it as a form of punishment. However, the practice later evolved to become part of the educational curricular. Despite its enormous benefits, some experts believe it is counterproductive and harmful to students’ health. Is homework given […] ... Perhaps the worst thing about assigning homework as punishment is that it sends a mixed message about the purpose of homework. Students might begin to regard regular homework as both unnecessary and a punishment rather than as a way to reinforce what is being learned in the classroom. ... May 31, 2022 · He was the person who invented homework in far 1905 and made it a punishment to his students. Since time when was homework invented, this practice has become popular around the world. Who was the first person to get homework? Roberto Nevelis of Venice, Italy, is often credited with having invented homework in 1095—or 1905, depending on your ... ... Is Homework a Punishment? The Italian pedagog, Roberto Nevilis, who invented homework, initially used it as a form of punishment. However, the practice later evolved to become part of the educational curricular. Despite its enormous benefits, some experts believe it is counterproductive and harmful to students’ health. ... ">

homework is punishment

Debunking the Myth of Roberto Nevilis: Who Really Invented Homework?

  • By Emily Summers
  • February 18, 2019

For those of us who have attended a formal education setting, you might remember the frustration of getting homework from most of your teachers. Before class ends, your teacher instructs your class to answer a certain page of your book or to write an essay about the topic you had just discussed.

Some of us really didn’t like doing homework. It was very time-consuming and, on top of extra-curricular activities, house chores, and other tasks you needed to do, you had very little time to yourself and your hobbies before having to go to sleep.

If you’ve ever been curious enough to find out who to thank for inventing homework, Google and several websites will tell you that it’s a man named Roberto Nevilis. That he invented homework as a form of punishment for underperforming students and, almost a thousand years later, billions of students are frustrated both at school and at home because of him.

But that, like a lot of things on the internet, simply isn’t true. In fact, Roberto Nevilis doesn’t even exist.

Who Invented Homework? Not Roberto Nevilis.

The nail in the coffin, a brief history on the education system, the father of modern homework, is homework still effective.

Online, there are many articles claiming that Roberto Nevilis was the first educator who came up with giving students homework. But if you look at the websites that claim this, you’ll find that it’s mostly forum websites or obscure educational blogs. No credible website or news source even mentions the name Roberto Nevilis. And for a guy who has affected the educational career of anyone who has had a formal education, you’d think a credible website would mention him at least once. Or some of the less-credible websites would confirm his contribution without saying the word “allegedly” or a vague “scientists believe” or the like.

Roberto Nevilis

Nevilis was supposedly a teacher based in Venice, Italy when he invented homework. Some claim that he invented it in 1095, while others claim he invented it in 1905 before it spread to Europe and to the rest of the world. It was said to be a form of punishment for students who underperformed in class. Students who performed well in class were spared from homework.

Either way, this claim is dubious. In 1095, education was still very informal around Europe and an organized education system in the continent didn’t start until 800 years later. In the 1500’s, English nobility were still being taught by private tutors.

Around 1095, the Roman Empire had long fallen and the Pope was still organizing the very first crusade and education was still informal, so it would be impossible for Nevilis to not only hold a class and give out homework, but to also spread out his idea to the rest of Europe when there was still no organized educational system.

And it couldn’t have been 1905, either. In 1901, California passed an act that banned homework for students younger than 15 years old before the law was revoked in 1917. That means Nevilis – assuming he does exists and isn’t the work of some internet trolls – couldn’t have invented it in 1905 in Europe if it already made its way to California and probably the rest of the world four years earlier.

And if that’s not enough evidence, just take a look at all the information you can get on him online. The only websites that mention his name: Quora, WikiAnswers, clickbait articles, and blogs for websites that help you write your homework (though if they can’t do their research properly, you might want to stay away from their services).

There’s no credible website mentioning him anywhere. And the websites that do mention him are very vague in describing his contribution. “Scientists believe” becomes a very sketchy claim when a website doesn’t cite a credible source. And if you try to search “Roberto Nevilis,” only the same handful of websites show up.

The truth is, homework existed dating back to the earliest civilizations and the first forms of education. In feudal times, education was reserved for the wealthy men. Those who weren’t rich had no time to study reading or philosophy and were busy making a living. Wealthy young women were trained in the more womanly arts, though princesses and nobles were expected to know a few things and were tutored as well. While they weren’t given workbooks and links to online quizzes, their tutors had expected them to read literary pieces during their free time.

homework

The earliest evidence of a formal school comes from the Sumerian civilization. They had Edubas, which were houses of clay tablets were scribes practiced how to read and write. Archaeologists found student exercises etched into the tablets. Not much is known if they followed a schedule or were all taught by one teacher like the education system today.

During these times, however, homework did not involve answering questions or writing down essays as we’ve come to know it today. If we look back at history, there were other forms of educational methods that students and teachers at the time would have considered the homework of their time.

While we can’t pin the invention of homework to a certain teacher, we can trace back who was responsible for making homework that way it is to this day: Johann Gottlieb Fichte, a German philosopher known as the founding father of German nationalism.

Johann Gottlieb Fichte

In 1814, Prussia had a problem stirring nationalism among its citizens. Instead of serving the country after the war, citizens could choose to go back to whatever they were doing without thinking of dedicating their time and sacrifice to the country. There was no sense of pride or nationalism.

And so, Fichte conceived the Volkschule – a mandatory nine-year education similar to primary and lower secondary education provided by the state – and a Realschule – a secondary school available to aristocrats. Those attending the Volkschule were given the homework we know today as a way to demonstrate the state’s power even during personal time.

The system spread across Europe, but not in a totally dominating way. Some countries continued with their own system, which is why countries such as Finland don’t impose homework on their students. However, in 1843, back when the United States still practiced private tutors or informal lessons, Horace Mann reformed public education after travelling to Prussia and saw their education system and adapted it into the American education system. Thus, homework eventually evolved into a global practice.

Homework, therefore, is the result of nationalism and getting students to understand that “me time” actually falls on government time if they want to get their education. Contrary to what many websites would say, it wasn’t invented as a punishment for academically failing students.

However, over 200 years had passed since homework’s evolution into what we know it is today. So, is it still necessary to keep our students burdened with extra assignments? On one hand, it can be a good way to teach students time management skills. We like to think that work stays at work and personal life stays out of work, but as working adults, we know this is not the case. Homework at an early age teaches students to use their time wisely.

And while homework can still be helpful in students’ education, it’s only helpful to a certain extent. When plenty of teachers pile on homework, they’re depriving students of time to focus on their extra-curricular activities and personal life.

homework

For those of us who have graduated with high grades, we’ve learned the hard way that a spotless report card can get our foot on the door, but if we have poor interpersonal skills and lack the skills you can only get outside of academics, you can’t achieve total success. Homework is good, but only to an extent. Then, it just becomes an unnecessary burden on students.

In fact, if you look at Finland and Japan – countries that don’t practice giving out homework – you can see that homework is unnecessary if the educational system favors it. Finland has shorter school days, longer summer breaks, and have an educational system where students aren’t required to start school until the age of seven. However, their students have always ranked high in terms of exams.

It’s because in Finland, a teaching career is at the same league as doctors and lawyers. Compare that to our current education system, where teachers are underappreciated and harried in public schools. Finland’s education system allows students more leeway, showing how it is possible to produce bright students without putting too much pressure on them.

We’ve all been frustrated with homework back when we were studying, but homework is actually more than just a nuisance we all have to face in our educational career. It’s actually an important factor which can shape productivity and the time students have for other factors of their education.

About the Author

Emily summers.

homework is punishment

10 Careers That Are Hands On

homework is punishment

Exploring Trade School Types for Home Improvement Professions

homework is punishment

Why Should You Invest in Social Media Marketing?

homework is punishment

A Brief Outline of The Education You Need to Becoming a Professional Roofer

homework is punishment

Is the D Important in Pharmacy? Why Pharm.D or RPh Degrees Shouldn’t Matter

homework is punishment

How to Email a Professor: Guide on How to Start and End an Email Conversation

homework is punishment

Everything You Need to Know About Getting a Post-Secondary Education

homework is punishment

Grammar Corner: What’s The Difference Between Analysis vs Analyses?

graduate

THE COLONEL NEWSMAGAZINE

Ledyard high school / ledyard, ct.

homework is punishment

Homework, a Cruel Punishment?

Was homework actually created as a punishment? Or is that just a common misconception? For decades, students have been tortured with homework that can take them anywhere between five minutes to two hours to complete. Students are becoming more and more stressed, and spend an average of seven hours a week on homework.  

Roberto Nevilis is considered the first real “inventor” of homework. According to college-homework-help.org , Nevilis is said to have created it as a punishment for students who were underachieving in his class, but those who were succeeding were exempt from completing these tasks. But the truth is, the earliest signs of education dated back to the Sumerian civilization. There are said to be houses of clay tablets with student exercises of reading and writing scratched onto them. 

Everyone knows students get stressed out from the amount of homework they are assigned, but does everyone know the physical struggle students go through? “In 2013, research conducted at Stanford University found that students in high-achieving communities who spend too much time on homework experience more stress, physical health problems, a lack of balance in their lives, and alienation from society.” This study proves that homework has more of an effect on students than teachers realize. Students have an average of more than three hours of homework each night, adding up to an average of seven hours per week. 

The stress that comes from loads of homework can cause students to become sleep-deprived, which can cause a decrease in their performance in school. “When it came to stress, more than 70 percent of students said they were “often or always stressed over schoolwork,” with 56 percent listing homework as a primary stressor. Less than one percent of the students said homework was not a stressor,” says Sandra Levy from healthline.com.  

Every day students come home after hours of learning, to sit and again force themselves to learn some more. With an average of three hours on homework a night plus seven hours of school, students nowadays are involved with extracurriculars more than ever, which adds even more stress on students, giving them more work than the average student has. According to the United States Census Bureau, 57 percent of students between the ages of six to 17 participate in extracurricular activities. With all of this, students are being deprived of their social lives and instead stuck with the stress/anxiety levels of an adult. As the stress levels rise and the hours of sleep drop, students are receiving less and less sleep every night. Instead of getting a healthy 8-10 hours of sleep, which only 15 percent of teens receive, they are instead getting a maximum of six hours, which only 85 percent of teens currently receive. If teachers were less strict on students with homework, grades would be higher and students’ stress levels would be lower. 

Homework is an unneeded stressor that could be decreased by the amounts given. When the stress levels of kids get the best of them and restrict them from being a teenager and living their life, it has gone too far. The student should feel comfortable with their work and not have to stay up for hours finishing obsessive homework assignments. 

Sophomore Gia Figueroa is a staff writer for the 2019-2020 Colonel. She dances three days a week at a dance studio in Mystic taking four different classes. In her free time, you can usually find her hanging out with friends, painting, or just watching Netflix.

Sophomore Erin Buller is a staff writer for the 2019-2020 Colonel. She focuses mainly on cheerleading but also participates in volleyball in her free time. When she is not on the court or on the sidelines, she is at home watching a football game or the same YouTube channel for the 7th time.

Share this:

Tell us how you feel cancel reply.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

' src=

  • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
  • Subscribe Subscribed
  • Copy shortlink
  • Report this content
  • View post in Reader
  • Manage subscriptions
  • Collapse this bar

Was Homework Created As a Punishment?

fear of homework

Homework was not created to punish the students . Roberto Nevilis, an Italian teacher, invented it in 1905. The motivation behind Homework was quite simple. 

As a teacher, Nevilis believed that his lessons had lost meaning when they quit the classroom and went back to the comfort of their homes.

Saddened that the students could not perform better than themselves, he decided to adopt different strategies despite his efforts. This led to Homework being invented . 

The concept of Homework, as we know, is not the primary goal of Nevilis. Nevilis saw it more as a means to punishment since physical punishment was not an option.

Homework is essential to learning in school and is here to stay. But sometimes, kids need extra help to complete assignments, and schools and teachers should understand that every child is unique and should create homework assignments for each student versus generally for the whole class.

Table of Contents

History of Homework in the United States

In American culture, Homework was always frowned upon. Many students could not attend higher school, and many teenagers had to do chores and farm work. This made Homework a disliked subject by both parents and schools. 

Students dropped out of school because they couldn’t keep up with Homework. This was due to them mainly memorizing a text at home.

Parents complained at every level of society. In 1880, Francis Amasa Walker persuaded the Boston school board to ban math homework assignments for children under 15. Some people supported reforming Homework and, for example, making the lessons more relevant to students’ lives outside school.

After the Cold War ended, Homework became less popular.

United Kingdom

Students in Britain do more Homework than students from other European countries. The average weekly homework time for this subject is 5 hours. 

The significant difference in UK homework is that middle-class teenagers get more Homework than those from Europe and Asia.

Here are some things that might help your child learn better

1. here are some tips to make it easier.

  • Make sure your child has enough time to complete their Homework .
  • If your child needs more time, ask them what they want to work on next.
  • Ask your child how they feel about doing Homework.
  • Let your child choose the order of tasks.
  • Give your child choices when possible.
  • Don’t give up on your child.
  • Encourage your child to use technology to help with Homework.
  • Be patient.
  • Please help your child understand why they should try harder.
  • Have fun – Make Homework Fun and exciting.

Homework tips

2. Set aside time every day to complete assignments.

Many students say completing Homework is one of the most complex parts of the school. They often feel overwhelmed by the work they must do each night. This feeling can lead to stress and anxiety.

Setting aside time daily will make them more focused and disciplined in doing their Homework, after which they will be free to spend time on other hobbies or recreational activities.

3. Doing some Research will help

If you’re having trouble with your Homework, try doing some research first. Find out what topics you’ll cover in class and what assignments will be due. Then, make a plan to tackle your Homework. You might even want to set up an automatic reminder so you won’t forget.

4. Do your best assignment first thing in the morning

Many students say they struggle with Homework because they don’t start early enough. They often find themselves procrastinating until the last minute.

This means that when they finally sit down to do their Homework, they spend more time than necessary. Instead, try starting your Homework as soon as you wake up. That way, you’ll be ready to focus on your studies before school starts.

5. Write down what you need to remember.

If you’re having trouble remembering things, write them down. You might also use sticky or post-it notes to remind yourself of important facts.

Homework tips

Final Word – Was homework created as a punishment?

Homework is here to stay, regardless of who came up with the Homework or if you think it’s a punishment.

While Homework has many advantages, teachers must be aware of when and when to effectively utilize it as an instrument to enhance classroom learning instead of a substitute for classroom instruction.

Students required to do too many homework assignments experience anxiety, depression, and anger. Therefore, teachers and schools should ensure to keep Homework to the minimum.

It isn’t always helpful for students as it could hinder their ability to learn or play outdoors, which is vital to ensure the development of children. Therefore, Homework should not be treated as a punishment but as a tool to improve our child’s learning skills.

FAQ – Was Homework Created As a Punishment

How does homework benefit students.

Homework helps students consolidate their understanding of a subject, develop good study habits, and increase academic independence. It’s a proven concept, hence widely used globally.

How much Homework is considered appropriate for students?

The amount of Homework considered appropriate varies by age and subject, but it is generally recommended that students receive 10-30 minutes per night per grade level.

Are there any drawbacks to Homework?

Too much Homework can lead to stress and burnout and negatively impact a student’s home life and relationships. It is vital to strike a balance between homework and leisure time.

Who Created Homework and Why?

The origin of Homework and who created it is not well documented, and there are varying accounts. However, one widely accepted story is that Homework was introduced by Roberto Nevilis, an Italian teacher, in the early 20th century to keep students occupied outside school hours.

According to this story, Nevilis was frustrated with students not completing their classwork, so he punished them with additional work to complete at home.

However, this story has been largely discredited, and no concrete evidence supports it. The use of Homework has been a part of education for centuries. Its purpose has evolved to reinforce learning and allow students to practice and apply concepts learned in class.

Share this:

  • May 23 Classical Academy says goodbye to first-ever Saudi Arabian foreign exchange student
  • May 23 Senior Brady Goe receives lucrative baseball scholarship
  • May 10 Chess World Championship Tournament Ends in a Victory for Chinese Grandmaster
  • January 31 Did Knives Out Age Like Milk?
  • January 25 See How They Run: An Wall-Breaking Whodunnit

Classical Academy High School's Online News Site

Entertainment

Homework: The True Reality Behind It

Sophia Wecker , Editor | March 16, 2021

Photo provided by Sigmund

Photo provided by Sigmund

Homework. Something almost everyone in school—  no matter what age, grade or where they live—  all dread. But, why do we have homework?

In 1905, an Italian teacher named Roberto Nevilis invented the concept of “homework.” Originally, its purpose was to be used as a punishment for students who were lazy in class or for those who were disobedient or rude to their teacher. This practice became popular and became more frequently used around the world. A few years after it was invented, it became a standard thing that almost all teachers worldwide began regularly giving out to students after school every day or most days. 

Students are usually mentally and physically drained when they come home from school, sports, or after they go somewhere after school and having homework assigned to them puts more even stress onto their plates. Whereas other students might like homework or enjoy doing it because it can benefit them academically or might help with avoiding boredom. Either way, there are both positive and negative sides to homework. 

Nowadays, teachers assign homework for either what was left over from class or for extra work to help expand upon the topics taught while in school. But, is that really a smart and good reason to assign homework? Like what was mentioned earlier, students like to come home after a long day of school and relax and have some downtime or possibly hang out with their friends and/or family. But if they have assignments that could take them multiple hours to do that are all due by midnight, this erases this precious free time for students. 

Though we may hate to admit it, there are some upsides to homework. Students who need extra help or practice on a topic or subject may benefit from additional work through their homework. Others might like some extra practice to better their understanding or to possibly get ahead in a subject to get higher test and quiz scores. 

Despite the extra help homework gives, it’s not always necessary. Like mentioned earlier, some students may have a hard time completing homework because of time, their own individual lives and it just might not be needed for some students so it shouldn’t be necessary for them. 

Although homework is annoying and isn’t always necessary, we need to continue to do our best and complete this task because it will benefit us later in life. But I do ask teachers to give students a break or to give them time to rest up after long and hard days. On a personal note, homework has always been a struggle for me to get done because of my busy schedule, but as mentioned before, I do ask teachers to give less or no homework, out of the courtesy of students’ time. Although we might need homework for extra help, those who do excel and are carrying good grades in a class do not need extra work. Teachers, please take from this article and help the students in your classrooms to do their best, not by giving them homework, but by understanding their circumstances and their own individual lives. 

Korean Girl Group Red Velvet on the red carpet of an awards show

Red Velvet – Your Sweet New Obsession

Spotify's Newest Non-Genre

Spotify’s Newest Non-Genre

Photo by Sebbi Strauch on Unsplash.

Rating Halloween Candy as Someone Who Hates Food

Grab a book, make some cocoa, and snuggle under a blanket! Time to relax! Photo by Elly Hamilton.

Mental, Physical, and Emotional: Keep Yourself Healthy

Photo by Marco Bianchetti on Unsplash

Dear Discouraged Student

2023's world chess champion, Ding Liren, studies the board.

Chess World Championship Tournament Ends in a Victory for Chinese Grandmaster

The movie poster for Knives Out

Did Knives Out Age Like Milk?

The movie poster for See How They Run (2022)

See How They Run: An Wall-Breaking Whodunnit

Decision To Leave - An Impressive Waste Of Time?

Decision To Leave – An Impressive Waste Of Time?

From an Irate Senior to CAHS Administration: A Letter Concerning the 2022-2023 Phone Policy

From an Irate Senior to CAHS Administration: A Letter Concerning the 2022-2023 Phone Policy

Comments (10).

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

Logan • Oct 20, 2022 at 11:28 am

if you are doing an essay on homework here are some more websites for 6-8th grade: Johnson, Geoff. “Piling Homework on Kids Is a Mistake That Undermines Work/Life Balance.” Times-Colonist, 09/05 2021. ProQuest; SIRS Issues Researcher, https://explore.proquest.com/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2578243016?accountid=65482 .

Moniuszko, S. M. (2021, 08/23). Heavy Homework Load May Be Detrimental to Health. USA TODAY https://explore.proquest.com/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2564234859?accountid=65482

Patterson, K. (2021, 11/09). Homework Isn’’t Helpful in First Grade Or in College. University Wire https://explore.proquest.com/sirsissuesresearcher/document/2617064023?accountid=65482

Logan • Oct 20, 2022 at 11:31 am

also the cites are in APA 7

ethan • Oct 17, 2022 at 7:07 am

you helped my essay

FreezingZozi • Oct 4, 2022 at 8:59 am

why don’t they give homework to students that want or need homework not everyone in a class

Ece • Oct 1, 2022 at 1:43 pm

tysm good story

Ali Syed Karim • Sep 25, 2022 at 6:43 pm

The fact that homework is for all students is annoying, and its original use was just for students who were lazy or who were being disrespectful and disobedient in class. I hate homework.

James • Jun 7, 2022 at 6:02 am

this is relay helpful

Matthew • Apr 7, 2022 at 12:27 pm

James • Jun 7, 2022 at 6:17 am

Karen • Aug 3, 2022 at 6:42 pm

Great story

CLJ

Home » College Of William & Mary » Why Was Homework Invented?

Why Was Homework Invented?

Table of Contents

In 1905, an Italian teacher named Roberto Nevilis invented the concept of “homework.” Originally, its purpose was to be used as a punishment for students who were lazy in class or for those who were disobedient or rude to their teacher . This practice became popular and became more frequently used around the world.

Who came up with homework and why?

An Italian pedagog Roberto Nevilis is considered the real “inventor” of homework. He was the person who invented homework in far 1905 and made it a punishment to his students. Since time when was homework invented, this practice has become popular around the world.

Who was the first person to get homework?

Roberto Nevelis of Venice, Italy, is often credited with having invented homework in 1095—or 1905, depending on your sources.

Is homework a waste of time?

Homework is taking up a large chunk of their time, too — around 15-plus hours a week, with about one-third of teens reporting that it’s closer to 20-plus hours. The stress and excessive homework adds up to lost sleep , the BSC says.

Was homework meant to be a punishment?

Does homework actually help.

Homework helps to reinforce classroom learning, while developing good study habits and life skills . Students typically retain only 50% of the information teachers provide in class, and they need to apply that information in order to truly learn it.

Is California banning homework?

In the early 1900s, Ladies’ Home Journal took up a crusade against homework, enlisting doctors and parents who say it damages children’s health. In 1901 California passed a law abolishing homework !

What does homework stand for?

Half Of My energy Wasted On Random Knowledge Product Description. Homework stands for “ Half Of My energy Wasted On Random Knowledge “.

How do I stop stressing my grades?

Stop stressing about your college grades and do these fun things instead

  • Set milestones and rewards. Source: Giphy.
  • Sleep more. Snuggle in.
  • Play sports. Sweat out those frustrations!
  • Join a club or fraternity. Your stress could be owed to a lack of outlets to unload.
  • Hang out with your friends. An alternative form of therapy.

Should homework be banned?

Homework in elementary school has not been shown to lead to better achievement in school . And too much homework in the higher grades can lead to worsening grades and increased mental and physical issues. So it’s important to be mindful of how much time your child is spending on it each day.

Is 3 hours of homework too much?

That study, published in The Journal of Experimental Education, suggested that any more than two hours of homework per night is counterproductive. However, students who participated in the study reported doing slightly more than three hours of homework each night, on average .

What country gives no homework?

The truth is that there is nearly no homework in the country with one of the top education systems in the world. Finnish people believe that besides homework, there are many more things that can improve child’s performance in school, such as having dinner with their families, exercising or getting a good night’s sleep.

Who created school?

Horace Mann Horace Mann is considered as the inventor of the concept of school. He was born in 1796 and later became Secretary of Education in Massachusetts. He was a pioneer in bringing educational reforms into society.

Does homework cause depression?

However, when homework exceeds, it affects their emotional well-being making them sad and unproductive students who would rather cheat their way through school . Studies documented in the Journal of Experimental Education conclude that homework that exceeds two hours is counterproductive to the health of students.

Who made homework a daily thing?

Going back in time, we see that homework was invented by Roberto Nevilis , an Italian pedagog. The idea behind homework was simple. As a teacher, Nevilis felt that his teachings lost essence when they left the class.

How much homework is too much?

How much is too much? According to the National PTA and the National Education Association, students should only be doing about 10 minutes of homework per night per grade level . But teens are doing a lot more than that, according to a poll of high school students by the organization Statistic Brain.

Does homework affect sleep?

Too much homework can result in lack of sleep , headaches, exhaustion, and weight loss”. Similarly, Stanford Medicine News Center reports that the founder of the Stanford Sleep Disorders Clinic stated, “’I think high school is the real danger spot in terms of sleep deprivation,’ said William Dement, MD, Ph.

Why should teachers not give homework?

Studies have also shown that too much homework can be very unhealthy, making students feel stressed and burnt out . Most teachers give about 1-2 pages of homework which may not seem like a lot but when you add them up it can easily overwhelm a student.

Is homework illegal in the UK?

There have even been subsequent questions about its legal status. Just to be clear: schools are not obliged to set homework, and some don’t . But when schools do set homework, children do need to do it.

Is homework illegal in Canada?

In Canada, some teachers have no-homework policies and a few schools have banned it outright .

Is a homework illegal?

Homework is legal in all US states as there are no state laws banning them . However, schools in different states are free to have their own rules about homework. Some states where some schools (or districts) have banned or limited homework include: Utah.

Avatar photo

By Edmund Duncan

Edmund Duncan is an education expert and thought leader in the field of learning. He has dedicated his life to helping students achieve their full potential in the classroom and beyond.

Edmund's work as a teacher, administrator, and researcher has given him a unique perspective on how students learn and what educators can do to foster a love of learning in their students. He is passionate about sharing this knowledge with others, and he frequently speaks at education conferences around the world.

When Edmund isn't working or speaking, he enjoys spending time with his family and friends. He loves traveling and exploring new places, and he is an avid reader who loves learning about new cultures and customs.

You might also like:

Is william and mary a dry campus, is william and mary for rich kids, is william and mary the oldest college in america.

Logo

  • Mathematics
  • Earth science
  • Does homework make you smarter?
  • Homework is a punishment
  • English homework ideas for High School
  • Should homework be banned?
  • Pros and cons of homework
  • Too much homework
  • How to get motivated
  • Writing tips
  • Looking for chemistry answers

© 2013 - 2024holidaysforquince.com

Is Homework a Punishment?

The Italian pedagog, Roberto Nevilis, who invented homework, initially used it as a form of punishment. However, the practice later evolved to become part of the educational curricular. Despite its enormous benefits, some experts believe it is counterproductive and harmful to students’ health. According to them, take-home assignments are stressful and overburden students. What do you also think? Is homework a punishment? Now let us try to find answers to this question.

When Homework for children started

Until the 20th century, children were exempted from homework. Their learning started and ended in the classroom. The phenomenon changed when experts concluded that the brain is a muscle, which could be strengthened with mental exercises. Consequently, homework was adopted for all levels of the education ladder. The practice has since been amended in many ways with some additions and subtractions.  The National Education Association (NEA) and National PTA (NPTA) adopted standard practice for programming homework is 10 minutes per grade level. However, teachers mostly disregarded this standard.

Why homework is punishment for kids

Imagine bringing unfinished office work home almost every day and virtually turning your house into an office extension. Even as an adult, you would not want to continue your office jobs at home. The best practice has always been, the time you close from work should be your last connection with work. Any other thing must wait until the next day. This is important because you need a fresh and rejuvenated mind for the next day’s work.

Kids also have the same feeling when given take-home assignments. After spending about 8 hours in the classroom, the brain is already tired of extra work. At that point, the only thing they deserve is enough rest for a revitalized mind and not additional loads of work. They also need to undertake extra-curricular activities like socializing and building their skills and talent.

Research has proved the importance of programming homework help for children's development. The truth is, there is a connection between getting assistance and students' achievement. Nonetheless, it failed to address the possibility of children achieving the same or better results when allotted an hour of school hours to do their assignment.

It is not to say that kids should be freed from continuing the learning process whiles home, but what is the need for overburdening them. Why should kids be given about two hours, take-home assignments? What happened socialization and playing with friends? What about pursuing their interest, which is also core in kids’ development. They need to play games, watch their favorite programs, and help their parents at home. 

Learning is good, but several other important aspects of life make childhood complete. Let us not forget about the health implications of too many assignments. Stress and its related symptoms like headaches, weakness, sleeplessness, and fatigue can push the kid into using drugs later. So in all, educators must reduce the amount of homework they assign kids. Parents should also be involved in advocating for the same during the PTA meeting. 

IMAGES

  1. Cory and Dee in Homework Ear Punishment (DVD)

    homework is punishment

  2. Homework Slave Punishment (SD)

    homework is punishment

  3. Homework Slave Punishment mobile

    homework is punishment

  4. Teacher Fucked His Student as Punishment for Not Completing Her Homework

    homework is punishment

  5. Cory and Dee in Homework Ear Punishment (Dial)

    homework is punishment

  6. Lady Alicia

    homework is punishment

COMMENTS

  1. Debunking Myths: No, “Roberto Nevilis” Didn’t Invent Homework ...

    Feb 18, 2019 · Is Homework Still Effective? Homework, therefore, is the result of nationalism and getting students to understand that “me time” actually falls on government time if they want to get their education. Contrary to what many websites would say, it wasn’t invented as a punishment for academically failing students.

  2. Why Homework Is A Punishment? - CLJ

    May 31, 2022 · But, why do we have homework? In 1905, an Italian teacher named Roberto Nevilis invented the concept of “homework.” Originally, its purpose was to be used as a punishment for students who were lazy in class or for those who were disobedient or rude to their teacher. Is homework harmful […]

  3. Homework - Wikipedia

    [38] [39] Homework without professional feedback from the teacher has little effect on the learning success of students. [40] Even if it is generally not wanted by homework distributors (unless homework is given as a punishment), completing homework may take up a large part of the student's free time.

  4. Homework, a Cruel Punishment? – THE COLONEL NEWSMAGAZINE

    Nov 22, 2019 · Roberto Nevilis is considered the first real “inventor” of homework. According to college-homework-help.org, Nevilis is said to have created it as a punishment for students who were underachieving in his class, but those who were succeeding were exempt from completing these tasks. But the truth is, the earliest signs of education dated back ...

  5. Was Homework Created As a Punishment?

    Sep 3, 2022 · The concept of Homework, as we know, is not the primary goal of Nevilis. Nevilis saw it more as a means to punishment since physical punishment was not an option. Homework is essential to learning in school and is here to stay. But sometimes, kids need extra help to complete assignments, and schools and teachers should understand that every ...

  6. Homework: The True Reality Behind It - Crimson

    Mar 16, 2021 · Homework. Something almost everyone in school— no matter what age, grade or where they live— all dread. But, why do we have homework? In 1905, an Italian teacher named Roberto Nevilis invented the concept of “homework.” Originally, its purpose was to be used as a punishment for students who were lazy in class or...

  7. Is Homework A Punishment? - CLJ

    May 31, 2022 · Is Homework a Punishment? The Italian pedagog, Roberto Nevilis, who invented homework, initially used it as a form of punishment. However, the practice later evolved to become part of the educational curricular. Despite its enormous benefits, some experts believe it is counterproductive and harmful to students’ health. Is homework given […]

  8. Homework and Tests as Punishment for Misbehavior

    Perhaps the worst thing about assigning homework as punishment is that it sends a mixed message about the purpose of homework. Students might begin to regard regular homework as both unnecessary and a punishment rather than as a way to reinforce what is being learned in the classroom.

  9. Why Was Homework Invented? - CLJ

    May 31, 2022 · He was the person who invented homework in far 1905 and made it a punishment to his students. Since time when was homework invented, this practice has become popular around the world. Who was the first person to get homework? Roberto Nevelis of Venice, Italy, is often credited with having invented homework in 1095—or 1905, depending on your ...

  10. Why Homework Is A Punishment For Kids

    Is Homework a Punishment? The Italian pedagog, Roberto Nevilis, who invented homework, initially used it as a form of punishment. However, the practice later evolved to become part of the educational curricular. Despite its enormous benefits, some experts believe it is counterproductive and harmful to students’ health.